10th grade respond, 11th grade comment on a 10th grade entry:
Should we make judgements on individuals based on one comment or action? Why or why not? Please respond in a good paragraph.
Apr 28, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
About Mrs. Atkinson
- Mrs. Atkinson's Musings
- Detroit, MI, United States
- I am a dedicated English teacher who believes that my students are the future. I am a life-long learner and hold a MSEL in Curriculum and Instruction from Concordia University in Ann Arbor. I earned my teaching credentials at Madonna University in Livonia, Michigan. I also hold a BA in English Linguistics from Eastern Michigan University.
30 comments:
It depends on the action the individual make. No,because people may do stupid stuff because they have to.Or they may do stupid stuff to make a living such as a drug dealer.Or maybe the person may not know what they are doing or saying so you may not want to judge people. Thats why i feel that you shouldmt judge people on there action and comments
You can't make judgements by some one actions all the time. You can't judge a book by it's cover. A comment is just a figure of speech. Action speaks louder than words. You should watch what you say around anybody/actions too.
To me it depends on who makes the comment and how they make the comment. i believe if you want to make a commenet on somthing i said or did, i really dont have a problem with it. i belive that nobody has a reason to judge anyboby for what they did thats not your job. Thats how i feel on why you shouldn't judge anybod for what they said or did.
Saying one comment is good enough instead of your actions. But you still have to watch how you say things to someone so they wont get affended. If you choose to take action it has to be done respectfully. So it really dont matter if you comment or take action, as long as it's done in a mature and respectful manner.
I'm commenting on Josh's blog, I feel that it was a strong statement, but it could have been more specific. Like explaining what kinds of stupid things people today might be doing.And there was only two minor errors in your blog.When you stated people may do stupid stuff. You should have changed stuff to things because it sounds more professional. And the last error was the was you spelled shouldmt and it should have been spelled shouldn't. Those are the only things wrong with your blog but besides that it was a good response.
I think one action is not good enough to judge a person. You never know that person maybe having a bad day. I think it takes more than one event to judge a person.It is best to get to know someone before you judge them.
I think that we should do judgement based on actions because noone will really know how we feel if that don't see what exactly it is that we are talking about. That's why they say I can show you better than I can tell you. They also say that actions speak louder than words.
I believe that you shouldn't judge someone on one comment or action.The reason I believe this is because that you should never judge someone on one thing or do. You really have to get to know a person before you judge them. Because you never know if that comment or action was just a one time thing. But that doesn't mean that you shouldn't watch what you do or say around people. so that's why I believe you shouldn't judge someone on one comment or action.
I dont think you should judge people because of an action or a commment,I say that because you don't know why people made that action.I believe the samething with someone's comment,thats their opinion and they have the right to speak that without being judged for it.I dont think its ok at all to judge someone for doing or stating their opinion.
You can tell alot about a person based on how they act and what they say. It may be because their friends are acting that way. If i see someone stealing, i will automatically title that person as a thief. You should definitely watch what you say or do around people.
I am commenting on Heather's blog. I am totally agreeing with her on what she wrote. She had minor errors in grammar. Other than that it was fine.
I am commenting on Audra... I totally agree with what she says in her entry. People have good and bad days and we as a people shouldnt judge others just on what they said or what they do because you could look at them the next minute and see a totally different person that you saw earlier.
I am commenting on Josh's post. I do think it all depends on what that action is,m because it could be something major, or minor. I think it also depends on the person. For instance, if they are in the public eye or not.
I'm commenting on Heather's comment. I agree with what she said cause shes right, juding people on one thing they might say or do is wrong. You may take their comment completely different then what it was meant to be or it might of been a slip of the tonuge. So I feel you should give people a chance before you start juding someone.
I think you can make judgement from what people say and do. i think if someone wanted to say they was gonna try to steal something from me i would try to watch my stuff. If i saw someone steal something from somewhere else i would protect my self from anyone stealing my stuff. peoples actions thoughts and comments can determine many peoples thoughts on someone.
I Think you shouldn't judge someone based upon one comment or action.I think it takes more than one event to judge a person.You really have to get to know a person before you judge them.
I believe that you should not judge some body or comment on action's. The reason I believe this is because you should never judge someone on something they say or do becuase you never know what that person is going through and how they can take the things that is going on in their life!!!! you shopui;d give evryone respect
I agree with josh's opinion.Also I belive action speaks louder then words.So when someone makes a unjustived or crazy comment once they should'nt be judged for jus that u have u judge them on prior knowledge of the person.So i think we should'nt judge people for a comment or actin they made once.
I like how ced says that we should make comments and take action in a mature and respectful manner but he still has to take a stand in the response. If he believes more in one than the other he should say that he grees or disagrees within the opening statment. Aside from that fact he is a very good writer and should keep up his great work!!!!!!
i really feel that you should not judge someone cause of there actions or comments. Because it could be a mistake and be taking in a very wrong way.and if one indivisual does the same or do the same thing more than once then that is when it becomes a problem.
I think it depends on what that person says because if you keep saying something eventually those words can become actions. and that is why when we have a bomb threat the building must be evacuated imdiately.
i agree on what martrina said. and i wanna also add that if you don't like people talking about you why would you say something about somebody else? you don't know what they could be saying behind yo back.
No i dont think we should judge someone on one action or comment they.I believe this because the day you see somone doing something when you first meet them could just be a good dayfor them . Or it could be a bad day for them.
I don't think that you should judge someone by one comment or acton they made. at the same time it's not what you say it's how you say it. someone can say something meaning no harm but if they say it in the wrong tone then people want to get mad. me personally, i believe life is too short to spend it being mad at people especially over something as simple as a comment.
No because people should not even make decision on who they are its just wrong someone can be good person and you just mis-judge them wrong.
I completely agree with you Kayla. Nobody should be passing off judgements based off of what was, said, heard, or even seen. At the same time you do end up with some sort of an impression but you shouldn't stick to your first observation of them because in way that's still passing judgements. It's not our place to judge anyone, whether the person is offended by it or not.
I'm commenting on Ced's blog post. I see that you have a very strong statement about actions and what is being said. But what you have to understand from the blog question is whether or not it's appropriate to pass judgements on things that we have seen done by others or heard from others. True enough an expression or a sort of impression will be made if a situation occurs where there is something said or action has been taken that owuld draw a bad source of attention. But even still in that case, it's not our position to judge.
Aarion, I must disagree with your statement. Nobody should be judged even when you get to know the person or even see more events that would be considered bad choices. It's not in our right to judge anyone for any reason.
Nikki, I disagree with your statement because under no circumstances is it right to judge anyone whether you get to know them or not, the factof the matter is it's a wrong decision because just as you wouldn't want a person to judge you, passing judgement is being hypocritical.
Raymond I semi-agree with your statement. Even if the persn does do something wrong multiple times, that still does not give them the right to judge someone or prejudge them in that matter.
Post a Comment